An employment discrimination and retaliation case brought by a former associate at Ropes & Gray LLP will go to trial in November 2013, following a ruling on competing summary judgment motions, rules Judge Richard G. Stearns of the U.S. District Court (Massachusetts) in an Order released on August 16, 2013.
Plaintiff John H. Ray III alleges that Ropes & Gray LLP denied him promotion to partnership because of his African-American heritage. Most of these claims were dismissed following the firm’s summary judgment motion. Ray also argued the firm retaliated against him when he complained of discrimination. Those claims survived summary judgment.
The alleged retaliation included, among other things, the firm’s withholding of recommendation letters, which a jury could conclude was in retaliation for an EEOC filing by Ray. A further retaliation charge concerns the firm’s providing the EEOC’s initial “no cause” determination letter to the profession-oriented website, Above the Law. The letter included details about Ray’s performance reviews and an internal investigation into alleged criminal conduct by Ray. The firm argued the determination letter was not confidential, and providing it to the website was to correct Ray’s one-sided presentation of the facts.
The Court ruled, however, Title VII prohibits an employer from responding to protected activity (like an EEOC filing) by taking an action that would dissuade a reasonable worker from pursuing a charge of discrimination, and that the threat of dissemination of derogatory private information, even if true, would likely deter any reasonable employee from pursuing a discrimination complaint against an employer. The Court also noted that, by knowingly releasing damaging information about Ray, the firm arguably violated its own policy against dissemination information contained in employee personnel records.
For more information on professional liability matters, contact Attorney Bill Saturley at 603.410.1500 or a member of PretiFlaherty's Professional Liability Group.
Violation of FDCPA Not Necessarily a Violation of Massachusetts' Consumer Protection Act
Thursday, September 12, 2013
A Massachusetts law firm which violated the federal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act while trying to collect unpaid condominium fees did not necessarily violate the Massachusetts consumer protection act, according to a U.S. magistrate judge. McDermott v. Marcus, Errico, Emmer & Brooks, P.C., 09-10159-MBB, August 26, 2013.
The law firm violated the FDCPA by communicating directly with the plaintiff condo owner – not his attorney – and with the owner’s mortgagees without his consent, said U.S. Magistrate Judge Marianne B. Bowler. The judge then went on to find a per se violation of the state’s consumer protection act, Mass.G.L. 93A. But a recent decision of the Supreme Judicial Court, the state’s highest court, found that a violation of Massachusetts regulations designed to protect consumers in other contexts does not necessarily mandate liability under the Act. Klairmont v Gainsboro Restaurant, Inc., 987 N.E.2d 1247 (Mass.2013) established that a violation of such regulations is only a violation of Chapter 93A when the conduct leading to the violation is both unfair or deceptive and occurs in trade or commerce.
Since the law firm’s services to its client were aimed at resolving a private dispute – failure to pay condominium fees – and were not services distributed in a business context, they did not occur in trade or commerce, according to the judge.
Reaction to the decision has been swift, and along predictable lines. According to various news reports, consumer advocates fear the ruling will leave consumers with no remedy if a particular activity is not covered by other laws, pointing out that Chapter 93A has been used acted as leverage against numerous activities seen as violative of consumer interests in the past. Other commentators suggest this ruling is evidence of a continuing effort by the judiciary to prevent every potential claim from evolving into a 93A case.
For more information on professional liability matters, contact Attorney Bill Saturley at 603-410-1500 or a member of PretiFlaherty's Professional Liability Group.
The law firm violated the FDCPA by communicating directly with the plaintiff condo owner – not his attorney – and with the owner’s mortgagees without his consent, said U.S. Magistrate Judge Marianne B. Bowler. The judge then went on to find a per se violation of the state’s consumer protection act, Mass.G.L. 93A. But a recent decision of the Supreme Judicial Court, the state’s highest court, found that a violation of Massachusetts regulations designed to protect consumers in other contexts does not necessarily mandate liability under the Act. Klairmont v Gainsboro Restaurant, Inc., 987 N.E.2d 1247 (Mass.2013) established that a violation of such regulations is only a violation of Chapter 93A when the conduct leading to the violation is both unfair or deceptive and occurs in trade or commerce.
Since the law firm’s services to its client were aimed at resolving a private dispute – failure to pay condominium fees – and were not services distributed in a business context, they did not occur in trade or commerce, according to the judge.
Reaction to the decision has been swift, and along predictable lines. According to various news reports, consumer advocates fear the ruling will leave consumers with no remedy if a particular activity is not covered by other laws, pointing out that Chapter 93A has been used acted as leverage against numerous activities seen as violative of consumer interests in the past. Other commentators suggest this ruling is evidence of a continuing effort by the judiciary to prevent every potential claim from evolving into a 93A case.
For more information on professional liability matters, contact Attorney Bill Saturley at 603-410-1500 or a member of PretiFlaherty's Professional Liability Group.
American Arbitration Association Updates Commercial Arbitration Rules
Wednesday, September 11, 2013
The American Arbitration Association has amended its Commercial Arbitration Rules (effective October 1, 2013). The new rules include a number of enhancements intended to provide a more time efficient and cost effective process. Some of the most significant revisions include:
- a mediation step for all cases with claims of $75,000 or more (subject to the parties’ ability to opt-out)
- greater arbitrator control over discovery (including the ability to allocate costs and restrict the scope of discovery)
- the ability to apply for emergency relief
- a specific rule allowing the parties to file dispositive motions
- new preliminary hearing rules as well as remedies and sanctions for non-compliance
- new procedures for dealing with parties who refuse to pay arbitration fees
- Authority to issue sanctions for objectionable or abusive conduct
- Clarification regarding jurisdiction, confirming that the arbitrator has the power to rule on the arbitrability of any claim
11th Circuit Criticizes Employer and Its Lawyer in N-Word Case
According to the ABA Journal, the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals has upheld a $1 Million bias judgment on behalf of three black or bi-racial workers at Alabama State University. Those employees asserted they were subjected to a hostile work environment and retaliation, including being called the N-word by an African American superior.
Of particular interest to attorneys was the 11th Circuit’s unusually harsh words for Alabama State University’s lawyers. According to the ABA Journal, in the Opinion, the Appeals Court stated, “We are troubled by ASU’s attorneys’ inability to adhere to court procedures and deadlines…Timeliness is imperative in the practice of law, and attorneys should not expect sympathy from this Court due to their own carelessness.” This criticism stemmed in part from untimely filings of key motions and mistakes which compromised ASU’s appeal, the Court noting, “In short, ASU missed all applicable deadlines for filing a notice of appeal…accordingly, we do not have jurisdiction to decide (certain) issues.”
This Opinion is a reminder of how important it is for counsel to know the rules and procedures required by the court in which he or she is practicing, and to meet all deadlines. The downside of not complying with such rules is the loss of reputation and, worse, the compromising of the clients’ case.
For more information on professional liability matters, contact Attorney Simon Brown at 603.410.1500 or a member of PretiFlaherty's Professional Liability Practice Group.
Of particular interest to attorneys was the 11th Circuit’s unusually harsh words for Alabama State University’s lawyers. According to the ABA Journal, in the Opinion, the Appeals Court stated, “We are troubled by ASU’s attorneys’ inability to adhere to court procedures and deadlines…Timeliness is imperative in the practice of law, and attorneys should not expect sympathy from this Court due to their own carelessness.” This criticism stemmed in part from untimely filings of key motions and mistakes which compromised ASU’s appeal, the Court noting, “In short, ASU missed all applicable deadlines for filing a notice of appeal…accordingly, we do not have jurisdiction to decide (certain) issues.”
This Opinion is a reminder of how important it is for counsel to know the rules and procedures required by the court in which he or she is practicing, and to meet all deadlines. The downside of not complying with such rules is the loss of reputation and, worse, the compromising of the clients’ case.
For more information on professional liability matters, contact Attorney Simon Brown at 603.410.1500 or a member of PretiFlaherty's Professional Liability Practice Group.
Design Professionals May be Subject to the Jurisdiction of NH Courts Without Ever Setting Foot in the State
Thursday, August 29, 2013
The New Hampshire Supreme Court’s recent decision in Kimball Union Academy v. Genovesi, Case No. 2012-492 (N.H. June 28, 2013) sets forth an expansive view of personal jurisdiction in New Hampshire, which could subject out-of-state design professionals to the jurisdiction of New Hampshire courts for work they perform even if they never enter into any contracts in New Hampshire or perform any work in the state.
The facts as alleged by Kimball Union Academy were that it entered into a contract with JDE, Inc, a Florida corporation, to design and build a field house facility on its campus. Pursuant to the contract, JDE was required to supply an architect and an engineer, both licensed in New Hampshire, for the project’s design. Instead, JDE apparently hired Genovesi, a professional engineer residing in New Jersey who was not licensed in New Hampshire, to perform certain design work for the footings and foundation system of the field house. Kimball Union alleged that there were a number of problems with the design work prepared by JDE and the professional engineer, which prompted Kimball Union to terminate its contract with JDE and commence litigation.
The professional engineer argued that the case against him should be dismissed because he lacked the requisite contacts with New Hampshire to allow New Hampshire courts to exercise jurisdiction over him. Specifically, he alleged (1) all the work he performed on the project took place in his office in New Jersey, (2) he did not transact any business in New Hampshire because his involvement was solely with JDE, a Florida corporation, and its president, a Pennsylvania resident, and (3) he lacked any other contacts justifying jurisdiction because he never resided in New Hampshire, never owned any real property in New Hampshire, never advertised in New Hampshire, never had any business interests in New Hampshire, and had never even been in New Hampshire since a ski vacation more than thirty years before the circumstances of the case arose.
The New Hampshire Supreme Court rejected these arguments. The Court concluded that the professional engineer had sufficient contacts with New Hampshire to allow New Hampshire courts to assert jurisdiction over him because he was aware that the plans he was developing would be utilized in constructing a building in New Hampshire. Further, the Court concluded that the evidence showed that an integral part of his work was to ensure that the design of the building would fit the specifications of the location in New Hampshire. Accordingly, the Court concluded that Kimball Union could proceed with its action against him in New Hampshire.
The New Hampshire Supreme Court’s ruling should put all design professionals on notice that they may be subject to the jurisdiction of New Hampshire courts for work they perform on projects in the state even if (1) they are not licensed in the state, (2) do not contract directly with any New Hampshire entities, and (3) perform all of their work on the project outside the state.
For more information on professional liability matters, contact Attorney Nathan Fennessy at 603.410.1500 or a member of Preti's Professional Liability Practice Group.
The facts as alleged by Kimball Union Academy were that it entered into a contract with JDE, Inc, a Florida corporation, to design and build a field house facility on its campus. Pursuant to the contract, JDE was required to supply an architect and an engineer, both licensed in New Hampshire, for the project’s design. Instead, JDE apparently hired Genovesi, a professional engineer residing in New Jersey who was not licensed in New Hampshire, to perform certain design work for the footings and foundation system of the field house. Kimball Union alleged that there were a number of problems with the design work prepared by JDE and the professional engineer, which prompted Kimball Union to terminate its contract with JDE and commence litigation.
The professional engineer argued that the case against him should be dismissed because he lacked the requisite contacts with New Hampshire to allow New Hampshire courts to exercise jurisdiction over him. Specifically, he alleged (1) all the work he performed on the project took place in his office in New Jersey, (2) he did not transact any business in New Hampshire because his involvement was solely with JDE, a Florida corporation, and its president, a Pennsylvania resident, and (3) he lacked any other contacts justifying jurisdiction because he never resided in New Hampshire, never owned any real property in New Hampshire, never advertised in New Hampshire, never had any business interests in New Hampshire, and had never even been in New Hampshire since a ski vacation more than thirty years before the circumstances of the case arose.
The New Hampshire Supreme Court rejected these arguments. The Court concluded that the professional engineer had sufficient contacts with New Hampshire to allow New Hampshire courts to assert jurisdiction over him because he was aware that the plans he was developing would be utilized in constructing a building in New Hampshire. Further, the Court concluded that the evidence showed that an integral part of his work was to ensure that the design of the building would fit the specifications of the location in New Hampshire. Accordingly, the Court concluded that Kimball Union could proceed with its action against him in New Hampshire.
The New Hampshire Supreme Court’s ruling should put all design professionals on notice that they may be subject to the jurisdiction of New Hampshire courts for work they perform on projects in the state even if (1) they are not licensed in the state, (2) do not contract directly with any New Hampshire entities, and (3) perform all of their work on the project outside the state.
For more information on professional liability matters, contact Attorney Nathan Fennessy at 603.410.1500 or a member of Preti's Professional Liability Practice Group.
ISO Makes Changes to Its Commercial General Liability Coverage Forms
The Insurance Services Office (ISO) recently filed various changes to its Commercial General Liability Coverage (CGL) forms. Insurance experts expect that these changes, which became effective in most states in April 2013, will soon be widely adopted by carriers nationwide. Several of these changes could have significant impacts on risk allocation in construction contracts.
In the construction context, changes to the ISO’s Additional Insured (AI) endorsements could be particularly impactful. AI’s endorsements are frequently used as a means of contractual risk transfer in construction contracts. However, in light of the ISO’s revisions, contracting parties must take care to ensure that the 2013 ISO AI endorsements align with their contractual intent.
Willis North America’s Construction Practice publication, Blueprint, provides a helpful summary of several key changes to the AI endorsements and their potential impacts on construction contracting. Blueprint further discusses the interplay between the AI endorsements and various states’ laws, provides general tips for contracting parties, and considers the benefits and drawbacks to the use of non-ISO AI endorsements. Construction professionals who use AI endorsements in their contracts would be well-served by reviewing Blueprint’s helpful primer on this subject.
For more information on professional liability matters, contact Preti Flaherty Attorney Benjamin Piper at 207.791.3000 or a member of Preti's Professional Liability Practice Group.
In the construction context, changes to the ISO’s Additional Insured (AI) endorsements could be particularly impactful. AI’s endorsements are frequently used as a means of contractual risk transfer in construction contracts. However, in light of the ISO’s revisions, contracting parties must take care to ensure that the 2013 ISO AI endorsements align with their contractual intent.
Willis North America’s Construction Practice publication, Blueprint, provides a helpful summary of several key changes to the AI endorsements and their potential impacts on construction contracting. Blueprint further discusses the interplay between the AI endorsements and various states’ laws, provides general tips for contracting parties, and considers the benefits and drawbacks to the use of non-ISO AI endorsements. Construction professionals who use AI endorsements in their contracts would be well-served by reviewing Blueprint’s helpful primer on this subject.
For more information on professional liability matters, contact Preti Flaherty Attorney Benjamin Piper at 207.791.3000 or a member of Preti's Professional Liability Practice Group.
Virginia Attorney Suspended for Instructing Client to Alter His Facebook Page
Monday, August 26, 2013
According to the ABA Journal, a Virginia lawyer has agreed to a five year suspension for advising his plaintiff-client to clean up his Facebook photographs.
The client had sued a cement company for wrongful death after one of its trucks tipped over onto the vehicle he was driving, killing his wife. Prior to trial, opposing counsel requested screen shots of the client’s Facebook page. The lawyer then instructed a paralegal to tell the client to clean up his Facebook page. Following this instruction from the lawyer’s office, the client deleted sixteen photographs, including one in which he was holding a beer can and wearing a t-shirt with a provocative slogan. Defense lawyers recovered the photographs prior to trial, and jurors were told about the deleted photos. Only after the trial did the lawyer disclose to the court emails between him, the paralegal, and the client concerning the Facebook page.
According to the ABA Journal, as a sanction for the lawyer’s conduct, the trial judge ordered him and his client to pay $722,000 to lawyers representing the concrete company for their legal fees, and the judge reduced the client’s $8.5 Million jury award.
The Virginia Supreme Court later reinstated the verdict. The lawyer, however, was suspended for five years for violating ethics rules requiring candor toward the tribunal, fairness to opposing party and counsel, and prohibiting “dishonesty, fraud, deceit or misrepresentation.”
For more information on professional liability matters, contact PretiFlaherty Attorney Simon R. Brown at 603-410-1500 or contact a member of PretiFlaherty's Professional Liability Practice Group.
The client had sued a cement company for wrongful death after one of its trucks tipped over onto the vehicle he was driving, killing his wife. Prior to trial, opposing counsel requested screen shots of the client’s Facebook page. The lawyer then instructed a paralegal to tell the client to clean up his Facebook page. Following this instruction from the lawyer’s office, the client deleted sixteen photographs, including one in which he was holding a beer can and wearing a t-shirt with a provocative slogan. Defense lawyers recovered the photographs prior to trial, and jurors were told about the deleted photos. Only after the trial did the lawyer disclose to the court emails between him, the paralegal, and the client concerning the Facebook page.
According to the ABA Journal, as a sanction for the lawyer’s conduct, the trial judge ordered him and his client to pay $722,000 to lawyers representing the concrete company for their legal fees, and the judge reduced the client’s $8.5 Million jury award.
The Virginia Supreme Court later reinstated the verdict. The lawyer, however, was suspended for five years for violating ethics rules requiring candor toward the tribunal, fairness to opposing party and counsel, and prohibiting “dishonesty, fraud, deceit or misrepresentation.”
For more information on professional liability matters, contact PretiFlaherty Attorney Simon R. Brown at 603-410-1500 or contact a member of PretiFlaherty's Professional Liability Practice Group.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
