Change in Massachusetts Rule on Fee Agreements Illustrates Risk of Cross-Border Practice

Tuesday, April 30, 2013

With the increasing regionalization and consolidation of business clients everywhere, lawyers trying to best service those clients are tempted to practice in multiple jurisdictions at one time.  This complicates the process of maintaining one's professionalism standards, as we try to comply with the demands of more than one state.

Despite the many similarities among the New England states, for example, sometimes the differences can also be significant.  The different approach to fee agreements -- and whether they need to be in writing -- is an example. 

Maine, New Hampshire, and Massachusetts all require that contingent fee agreements be reduced to writing.  (Even in this seeming consensus, there are distinctions:  Massachusetts goes so far, for example, as to specify the number of copies that should exist, and how long the lawyer must maintain his copy.)  As of January 1, 2013, however, Massachusetts has extended the "writing" requirement to nearly all fee agreements.

Maine and New Hampshire continue to recommend that fee agreements be in writing, without requiring it.

The disparity raises questions of conflicts of law.  If one is admitted in both New Hampshire and Massachusetts, for example, and pursuing litigation in Boston for a New Hampshire-based client, which rule applies?  Is there a different answer for a Massachusetts-based client pursuing litigation in Maine? 

As our practices continue to get more complicated, so too, do the rules applying to us.  To learn more, contact a member of Preti Flaherty's Professional Liability Group.

Authored by:  William C. Saturley

REMINDER: A Carrier's Settlement May Not Protect an Agent from Liability

Monday, April 8, 2013


Did you know that under New Hampshire law an insurance agent is not necessarily protected by a legal settlement executed by the agent’s carrier? 
 
In Balamotis v. Hyland, II d/b/a State Farm Agent, 159 N.H. 803 (2010), the New Hampshire Supreme Court held that State Farm’s settlement with an Insured over a coverage dispute did not prevent a subsequent suit by the Insured against State Farm’s Agent for failure to procure insurance as instructed by the Insured. 
 
The settlement document at issue did not purport to cover “agents” of State Farm and referred only to its “heirs, administrators, executors, successors, and assigns.”  Accordingly, the later suit against the Agent was not prohibited.  Such a claim against the Agent, the Court held, is separate and distinct from a claim against the Insurer for payment under the policy.
 
If you have questions regarding your rights and risks as an insurance agent, one of our insurance law professionals can advise you.

First Circuit Articulates Strict Standard for Discovery Rule

Monday, April 1, 2013


In a recent opinion (RTR Technologies v. Carlton Helming), the First Circuit upheld a District Court’s grant of summary judgment in favor of the accountant, holding the plaintiff’s malpractice claim was time-barred because it was not filed within the three year limitations period as required under Massachusetts law.  In making its ruling, the Court held that the plaintiffs either knew or should have known about their potential claim when they sought a second opinion concerning the advice that they had been given.  The First Circuit articulated a very strict standing, holding that the discovery rule pertains only to those plaintiffs whose injuries are “inherently unknowable.” 

In RTR Technologies v. Carlton Helming, RTR Technologies, a company sued an accountant, who had provided services to the company from 2003 until 2008.  In 2005, the accountant convinced the company to amend the company’s 2002 tax return to re-classify entries on the company’s balance sheets from loans to the principal to income to the principal.  The principal of the company testified she disagreed with the advice, which led her to seek two other expert opinions on the issue, but she nevertheless agreed to the plan and filed the amended return.  A short time after the return was amended, the IRS filed a substantial tax lien against the company.  In 2008, the company hired a new accountant who filed re-amended tax returns for 2002.  The IRS then abated the tax lien.  The plaintiffs sued their previous accountant in Massachusetts state court in the fall of 2009.

The district court granted summary judgment in favor of the accountant holding the company’s malpractice claim was time-barred because it was not filed within the three year limitations period as required under Massachusetts law.  The company appealed the ruling, arguing the discovery rule should apply.  That rule, under Massachusetts law, holds that a cause of action accrues, and the statute of limitations begins to run, when a plaintiff knows or reasonably should know that she may have been harmed by a defendant’s conduct, even if the harm actually occurred earlier.  The company argued it was not aware of the accountant’s malpractice until 2008.  The First Circuit disagreed and found that the company was aware of both the putative injury (the tax liability) and the putative cause (the accountant’s advice to amend the returns) in 2005, evidenced by the fact the company disagreed with the advice at the time it was received, and had sought other opinions before amending the return in 2005. 

“The law normally ministers to the vigilant, not to those who sleep upon perceptible rights,” wrote the First Circuit in the opinion, warning plaintiffs who have constructive knowledge of an actionable legal claim but wait to pursue a cause of action. 
 
Written By: Erin Berry

The Minefield of Threats in Litigation

Monday, March 18, 2013

When negotiating to settle a lawsuit, can a lawyer gain leverage for his client by threatening to report the adversary’s actions to the criminal authorities?  What are the ethical limits on such threats, if any?  Do such threats expose the threatening lawyer to any criminal or tort liability of his own? 

William C. Saturley and Beth Kissinger recently co-wrote an article on these topics, “The Minefield of Threats in Litigation.”  The article was published in the Fall 2012 issue of the New Hampshire Bar Journal. 

The article examines whether threatening criminal prosecution or a report to a regulatory body is just “hard bargaining,” or whether it breaches ethical lines.  The answer varies, even amongst otherwise comparable jurisdictions such as those in the New England region, surprisingly.

The conflict in treatment stems, in part, from each jurisdiction’s adherence to different codifications of ethical standards.  The text of the 1969 version of the Model Code of Professional Responsibility, for example, is unequivocal on the subject of threats. DR 7-105(A) provides: “[a] lawyer shall not present, participate in presenting, or threaten to present criminal charges solely to obtain advantage in a civil matter.”  Under the 1983 Model Rules, by contrast, no direct prohibition is found.  Commentary to the Rules suggests that any attempt to improperly employ threats was already prohibited by other provisions of the Model Rules, such as Rule 4.4(a), which prohibits a lawyer from taking any action that “has the primary purpose to embarrass, delay or burden a third person.”

The article also examines possible criminal and tort liability, under New Hampshire law, for the use of such threats. 

The Minefield of Threats in Litigation

Lawyers on the move: steps to take before dancing with a lateral hire

Monday, March 4, 2013


William C. Saturley and Kenneth E. Rubinstein co-wrote a risk management article, “Lawyers on the move: steps to take before dancing with a lateral hire.”  The article suggests actions firms should consider taking prior to hiring a lateral attorney.  While the article is written specifically for law firms, the suggestions are applicable to all professional fields:
●  Verify the apparent skills, and the accuracy of credentials (such as academic history), of the prospective new hire.

●  Research both the disciplinary and malpractice claims history of the individual.
●  Interview others who have personal knowledge of the attorney’s performance.

●  Review recent work product of the prospective hire. (Make sure the work is that of the hire and not a supervised associate).

●  If the lateral is bringing business to the firm, consider potential conflicts of interest with existing clients.  In this regard, a recent change to Rule 1.6 of the Model Rules of Professional Conduct, and accompanying commentary, permits limited disclosure by a lawyer about clients he represents to a prospective new hiring firm, without prior client consent. 
●  Consider potential client relation problems (do the fee arrangements with the lateral’s clients conflict with the firm’s standard arrangements?).  Evaluate whether the lateral’s clients appear financially stable.

●  Define the lateral’s staffing expectations.
●  Make sure the firm’s administrative requirements (such as prior engagement letters, or compliance with assignment committee directives) will be adhered to by the lateral.

●  Consider deferring full partnership status to a lateral hire until a reasonable period of time has passed, to allow further evaluation of the candidate; and then closely monitor performance during that period of time.
●  If the firm requires disclosure of income tax returns from its existing partners, consider requesting a return and a personal financial statement from the prospect.

The article was published in the January 2013 issue of the Massachusetts Lawyers Journal, a publication of the Massachusetts Bar Association:  Massachusetts Bar Association : Lawyers on the move: steps to take before dancing with a lateral hire

Massachusetts High Court Voids Advance Waiver of Subcontractor Bond Rights

Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Last month, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court held that a contract provision that required a subcontractor to waive its bond rights for work to be performed on a public project was void and unenforceable.

The court explained its ruling by noting, among other things, that the bond requirement set forth in M.G.L. c. 149 § 29 was designed to benefit subcontractors who work on public construction projects, as these subcontractors lack the right obtain a mechanic's lien. The court noted that Massachusetts already prohibits advance mechanic's lien waivers, and the same policy reasoning should apply to prohibit advance waivers of bond claims.

Contractors and subcontractors should be aware that the court only discussed claims involving bonds supplied pursuant to M.G.L. c. 149 § 29, and this ruling does not necessarily apply to other payment bonds.

A copy of the court's decision in the matter of Costa v. Brait Builders Corporation and Arch Insurance Company (SJC-11011) can be found here. For further information, please contact Ken Rubinstein at 617-226-3868 or William Whitney at 603-410-1571

The Nuts and Bolts of Accountants Liability Insurance

Thursday, September 6, 2012

Most wise accountants purchase professional liability insurance to protect them against claims that may arise during the course of their professional duties.  This insurance will generally protect accountants regardless of whether the claims occur in the context of tax, planning, auditing, or other accounting work.  Nonetheless, Accountants Liability Insurance will not necessarily protect against all claims that can arise, and while insurance carriers are usually required to defend their insureds from claims that are even tangentially related to an accountants’ practice, the insurance carrier may not be required to pay any judgment or settlement that results.

Most policies exclude certain types of claims altogether.
Accountant’s professional liability policies cover only certain claims – typically described as claims for damages caused by any act, error, omission or personal injury arising out of the rendering of professional accounting services.  Should such a claim appear, consult your broker.  You may have other policies that could apply.  Your broker will tell you, though, that APL policies contain several specific exclusions from coverage.

Criminal and similar acts are excluded.
Physically or sexually assaulting a client does not constitute “professional services.”  Defrauding a client with a Ponzi scheme or lying to a client about the returns an accountant failed to file will also likely fail the test of coverage.  If the claim includes these allegations, the insurer will probably defend the case but will otherwise reserve its rights.  A final adjudication of such wrongful acts will undo your coverage.

Contractual claims are excluded.
By including allegations of breach of contract, a claimant may benefit from a longer statute of limitations.  While many APL policies exclude “contractual liability,” the caselaw increasingly blurs the distinction between the actions.  Experienced attorneys for claimants take this into account when drawing up complaints.